I
never ever read any self-help books. Correction - never ever read any self-help books.
Unfortunately the same word is used here for both tenses. Some friends
suggested books like the ‘Monk who sold his Ferrari’, 'Mars/Venus' series, and
so on. Life was uncomplicated and smooth until I met these books…..and then it
seemed like a tsunami hit me. Ah, so this explains why I behaved like that with
my childhood friend, why I did not go skiing, etc……digging out incidents from
the past to explain the present. Creating imaginary traumas and psychological
problems to explain all the mistakes in my life so far.
Here
are the contents from a typical book :
* Eat your lunch out in the park, in the sunshine.
Take a walk to the bistro, with friends. (so now I need a book to tell me how
to enjoy those things in life that are free!)
* Give and love unconditionally. Love is like a
catharsis. (okay, so now even falling in love has an ulterior motive –
betterment of oneself)!
* Send little notes to tell a person how special
(s)he is. (yeah right, does not matter if you do not see that person’s face for
a year)!
* Keep a pet…..(yup, bring a
pedigree dog and when one gets tired of him, abandon him at a shelter).
*
My
first question is to question these suggestions (or remedies to improve one’s
life). My second question is since when have we started needing something,
ironically a darned book instead of a family member, to tell us and remind us
of some of the most basic lessons in life? Shouldn’t being kind to people and
animals, giving love, socializing well and other such basic behaviour come
naturally to us? Or perhaps the sequence is such that one book creates
imaginary issues in our lives, another offers the explanations and yet another
gives us valuable ideas to get out of the rut!
Did
our previous generations also have such complex problems? Again, two questions
– is the problem really a show-stopper or are we making mountains out of
molehills; and is the solution itself being the cause for the problem here? We are not even traveling in circles, maybe we have something of a Moebius strip here!
Yes,
challenges have always been there for everyone. Some fought them, others
accepted and moved on in life, a few more whined and took the beatings and
called them ‘sacrifices’. Life went on. Puppies grow up on their own, detached
from their parents. I saw a touching film recently, “Ours, L’ ” about a sweet little bear
cub who loses his mother in an accident and has to face many foes and battle
several hardships and nightmares. In the wild, his only hope for love and
companionship is an adult male bear. The film ends with the bear cub getting
his first sleep in hibernation, without nightmares of any kind.
Is
a book or a guru really needed to one through life? Ignorance is bliss; some
issues were never issues during our grandparents’ era. Is ignorance really
peaceful? Knowledge is powerful but in the wrong hands, it can be destructive
or even bourgeois. Why the latter? Rumination over too many issues and by
potentially ‘unsuitable’ people can sometimes cause a lot of ‘unlearning’ of basic teachings and
even destroy the meaning of knowledge. One needs to have capability to
assimilate what one takes in. A swan can separate milk from water, not a duck.
On
similar lines, a doctor, a lawyer, an engineer…..all are very good, but when a
nation has hundreds of engineering and medical colleges, something is terribly
out of balance. Entrance exams, aptitude tests….yes, science is real, not
abstract….but, 4.0 GPA, gold medal, blah-blah-blah...says who? Who is that authority that is leading these rat races?
Rats floating along the tributaries to join the main river; making the rich
richer and meanwhile making causing fissures in their own lives. And lo! These
books to the rescue. New terms and solutions being invented to accommodate the
knotty lives of the rats so they can continue their professional lives
successfully. Compatibility, divorces, affairs, pre-marital, extra-marital,
atheism, believers, religion, masochistic, sadism, God complex, insomnia, stress, incest, molesting,……..wait
a minute! Were these issues not there since time immemorial?
No,
these nasty problems came only because of the ‘westernization’ of Indian
culture, is the argument some people put forward when we have these
discussions. This is news to me. Denying something and blaming that on a
foreign culture is cowardice. At the same time, thinking too much about such
issues could take it’s toll. Not everyone is a swan. Movies, books and cafe discussions over these topics only. Whatever happened to 'small talk'? Or is everyone feeling the need to get out of 'small talk' and think deep, lest they be considered inane? It is a tightrope walk.
What
if one lives life a day at a time? If someone is trying to be bossy at work,
telling them you do not like that. Or dealing a molester on the street with a
slap would be a quick action – he might pull out a knife in retaliation but at
least we are ‘living’, even if it is for the moment! Why not just live like that little bear? All creatures have souls, but humans are the most enlightened......some say. What kind of 'enlightenment' is this? This spark of life is
usually there in children as a natural instinct, but human adults tend to overprotect and mollycoddle. But
‘speaking out’ too much and too often, can be annoying as well. An extreme of
nothing would be ideal, yet so difficult a rule to follow.
Disclaimer : And
no, I have read none of those books mentioned above. Just scanned a few pages.
Neither am I facing any major problems in life (at least that is the perception)!
This blog is not supposed to a condensation of those books either…..like a T.V
broadcasting it’s own image broadcasting it’s own image…….to infinity! Neither am I trying to preach or instruct, since I do not know if I am a swan or a duck in the making! Ending on a spiritual note for a change - a verse I particularly like :
ये जग है दो घडी का सपना,
आँख खुली कोइ ना अपना |
अन्त्: काल कछु काम न आवे,
संग रहे हरी नाम ||
Close
Binumuscat,
Yes, help books may not help and sometimes actually cause new problems. Dat was my blog topic.....
Thanks for contributing to the blog.
Kalyanee
Reply | | Report Abuse
hi
help books are not helping me .... how may of the life really chaged reading a help book.. i doubt really the motivation behind the writing of help book.
regards
Binu
Reply | | Report Abuse
Geekunnel,
Thanks for stopping by!
Kalyanee
Reply | | Report Abuse
Hello!!!
nice thoughts!!!
"One needs to have capability to assimilate what one takes in. A swan can separate milk from water, not a duck. "
regards
geekunnel
Reply | | Report Abuse
Melody,
Nice to get a visit from you! ;)
I agree wid u. For people without family to advise, the books can help. Glad to see u got the main statement of dis blo - too much knowledge can kill.
Kalyanee
Reply | | Report Abuse
Kalyanee
I inadvertently left out a portion of my comment during copy-paste.
Please read 'These books may not have much utility otherwise' as 'These books may not have much utility otherwise. And nothing can replace innate intelligence and common sense.'
Thanks
Melody
Reply | | Report Abuse
Hey Kalyanee
! I learnt more from your blog than from these books
.
That was a nice, valid rant
On a serious note, you ask if we shouldn't be learning life's lessons from family instead of from a book. I guess, these books sell like hot cakes, because the family is long gone and in its place is a big void. This is especially so in Westen cultures where people are single, lonely and pretty much on their own. These books may not have much utility otherwise.
I agree with you though that knowing more than what we need to know can be self-destructive esp, half-baked knowledge in the wrong hands.
Regards
Melody
Reply | | Report Abuse
Anjala,
yes, my point was that one may get into a fix that was not there before, by reading a book when (s)he may not really need help in that area.

Yeah, cookery is also hot! Actually my next blog may be on that (if i find time to write, i.e.)
Thanks for the value added wid the comment!
Kalyanee
Reply | | Report Abuse
Reply | | Report Abuse
BM.
ain't going to work wid me! But good u liked the idea behind the blog.

Heehee....thanks for the condescending comment....
Irene,
Nice to see u agree! I've been trolling Sulekha as usual....thanks for asking!
Kalyanee
Reply | | Report Abuse
- 1
- 2
- 3
Displaying 1 - 10 of 29 Blog Comments